Save Pin
As soon as it's Harry Potter movie night at my place, this fudge with that butterbeer flair makes an appearance. Imagine big butterscotch, creamy white chocolate, and sweet caramel all swirling together in every bite. It's like a bit of Hogwarts right on the table.
This treat totally took off at our place after my kids asked for a big Harry Potter birthday bash. I whipped up three batches one week. Now anytime we want something magical but easy, this fudge is a must.
Delicious Ingredients
- Sweetened condensed milk: It keeps everything sweet and thick—the regular stuff (not low-fat) is where it's at if you want that dense texture
- Marshmallow crème: Brings a super soft, creamy texture—make sure it's nice and fresh so it melts fast
- Salted butter: This is what gives you that rich butterscotch kick and helps everything set up—spring for a decent brand for best results
- Caramel ice cream syrup: Extra caramel flavor that makes it taste just like real butterbeer—real caramel is better than butterscotch syrup here
- White chocolate chips: This is your smooth top layer—check that cocoa butter’s listed for good melting
- Granulated white sugar: Evens out the sweetness and helps the fudge firm up—just use the regular fine stuff
- Butterscotch chips: The real heart of that butterbeer flavor—go for a brand that isn’t waxy and has bold taste
Tasty Step-by-Step Directions
- Slice and Serve:
- Once everything’s chilled through, grab the edges of the parchment and pull it all out. To cut clean squares, dip a sharp knife in hot water and wipe between cuts. Serve these bites cold from the fridge or let them warm up to room temp if you want extra creamy layers.
- Chill Until Firm:
- Pop the whole pan in your fridge for a couple hours, or the freezer for close to an hour, until it's nice and set. The fudge should come away from the paper without any sticking.
- Melt in White Chocolate:
- Take the pan off the heat and stir in the white chocolate chips until they just melt—don’t keep going too long or it’ll get grainy. Spread this white chocolate layer gently over the semi-chilled base and smooth out to the edges.
- Make the White Chocolate Mix:
- With a clean pot, stir together the last of the marshmallow crème, butter, sweetened condensed milk, and sugar. Stir non-stop as it heats up. When it bubbles, drop the heat a bit and let it go two minutes, still stirring the whole time.
- Set the Bottom Layer:
- After mixing, pour the butterscotch layer into your lined pan. Tap the pan to flatten it out, then slide it in the freezer so it firms up while you do the next step.
- Blend in Butterscotch:
- Once you’ve bubbled the mix for four minutes, dump in the butterscotch chips. Take it off the burner and stir until melted and smooth—keep whisking a minute so the fudge thickens but still pours easily.
- Boil the Base:
- After you start seeing bubbles, set your timer for four minutes. Don’t walk away—keep stirring as it goes gold and thick. This way, you'll get fudge that’s easy to pour but holds its shape.
- Butterbeer Magic Start:
- Melt butter, marshmallow crème, sweetened condensed milk, sugar, and caramel syrup in a pot over medium-high heat. Stir non-stop as things start melting so nothing sticks or burns at the bottom.
- Get Your Pan Ready:
- Line an eight-inch baking pan with parchment paper and give it a quick shot of cooking spray. This keeps the fudge from sticking and makes it super simple to lift out later.
Save Pin
I always go back for that thick butterscotch middle. I remember making this for my niece’s first Harry Potter celebration—she wore her cape (homemade, of course) and said everyone had to grab a piece before we even started the games.
Storing Butterbeer Fudge
Stick any extras in a container with parchment or wax paper between stacked layers. It lasts about a week in the fridge, or up to two months in the freezer. If you freeze, let it sit out ten minutes so it’s soft and tasty again.
Simple Swaps
No salted butter? Just mix in a tiny pinch of salt in every layer if you’re using unsalted. Need it nut free? Double check those chips, just to be sure. Want more caramel taste? Swap caramel syrup for some dulce de leche.
Fun Ways to Serve It
Perfect for birthdays, any fantasy or wizard themed party, or in your holiday treat box. Goes super well with mugs of warm milk, spiced cider, or even a simple butterbeer knockoff drink. For a party tray, toss in some chocolate frogs or gummies for the best kind of magical spread.
A Touch of Magic
You might know butterbeer from Harry Potter—students sipped it all through Rowling's books. This fudge takes all those sweet, creamy flavors and brings them together with regular stuff you’ll find at the grocery store—no Hogwarts train ticket needed.
Save Pin
Common Questions
- → What's the trick to keeping white chocolate from getting clumpy?
Take the pot off the heat before adding your white chocolate chips and mix them in quick. Don't keep stirring too much—this keeps everything nice and creamy.
- → If I'm out of marshmallow crème, what else works?
No worries! Make your own with marshmallows and a splash of corn syrup, or whip up homemade marshmallow fluff instead.
- → How do I stash this fudge so it stays awesome?
Just pop it in a sealed container and slide it in the fridge. It'll be good for a whole week, staying soft and tasty.
- → Can I use butter that isn’t salted?
Sure thing! If you go unsalted, sprinkle in a touch of salt to even out the sweetness of your fudge layers.
- → Can I keep fudge in the freezer to eat later?
Yep! Separate the fudge with parchment, cover tight, and it’ll hang out in the freezer fine for three months. Let it thaw in the fridge before enjoying.
- → What's the best way to slice fudge neatly?
Grab a sharp knife and wipe it off after every cut. Make sure the fudge is cold so you get perfect squares every time.