Save Pin
Five kinds of cheese melt into a bubbly golden crust with rich cheesy goo inside. Every forkful is super creamy thanks to the cheese mix, making this dish a crowd-pleaser at any potluck or the best comfort food for cozy nights when everyone wants more.
The first holiday I brought this along, it vanished before most dishes even got a look. Now, folks always ask if I'm bringing it. Even folks who swear off mac can't keep their hands off seconds. I guess this convinced me I'm an official mac and cheese fan.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Ground mustard and paprika: bring some tang and warmth. Use smoked paprika for that campfire vibe if you want
- Black pepper and a bit of cayenne if you like: just enough pep and zing to keep things interesting. Nothing beats fresh cracked pepper
- Extra sharp cheddar: gives a punchy, classic cheese bite. It's worth it to grab a block and shred it yourself
- Smoked gouda or regular gouda: a touch of smoke and creamy texture. The fresher the wedge, the better
- Colby jack: so smooth and melt-in-your-mouth. Skip the pre-shredded and do it yourself for max flavor
- Kosher salt: seasons everything from pasta water to the end result. Just sprinkle in enough so nothing ends up bland
- Evaporated or whole milk: creates a lush base that stays smooth, not separated. Long shelf-life milk is handy in a pinch
- Egg: binds the sauce so it's thick and velvety
- Velveeta or American cheese: the secret to super creamy texture like the classic version
- Large elbow macaroni: more tube room means more sauce in every bite
- Seasoned salt, onion powder, garlic powder: all the little extras for mega flavor. Freshly opened seasonings pop more in a mellow dish like this
- Smoked gruyere or the regular stuff: throws in a little something fancy and lush. Go for a sturdy, aromatic block
- Unsalted butter: makes sure everything blends smoothly and adds richness without extra saltiness
Easy Steps
- Cover and Bake Everything:
- Tightly wrap your dish with foil sprayed on the underside so cheese won't stick. Pop it in for half an hour covered. Yank off the foil and bake for another 25 to 30 minutes to get a bubbling, browned edge. Wait 10 minutes so it thickens up enough to scoop clean
- Toss Together Mac and Cheese:
- Put your empty pot back on medium and let butter melt till sizzling. Pour in the drained pasta and stir to coat. Add your milk-egg-spice blend and mix till smooth. All that shredded cheese? Fold it all in now so every noodle is smothered but not totally melted yet. Spoon this goodness into the buttered dish, flatten the top, and sprinkle over the cheese you saved earlier for a golden finish
- Mix Milk and Spices:
- In a big pitcher, beat an egg into evaporated or whole milk, then whisk in every spice—onion and garlic powder, seasoned salt, paprika, mustard, pepper, and maybe cayenne if you're feeling spicy. Mix it real well so no spice clumps up in the sauce
- Boil Pasta:
- Fill your biggest pot with tons of water, bring it to a full-blown boil, and salt it well. Dump in the elbows, give a good stir to keep them from clumping, and cook them for about 10 minutes—just till tender, not falling apart. Drain right away
- Save Some Cheese on the Side:
- Get your oven hot at 350°F and grease a deep dish. Hold back half a cup of each cheese you’re using (not Velveeta though) and mix those together—that’s your magic topping for later
Save Pin
The smoky flavors from gouda and gruyere are my favorite part. My siblings and I once spent a snow day playing with cheese combos for mac, and this one became our household classic. That’s the day it really felt like our own signature dish.
Storage Advice
Stash any leftovers in a sealed box in the fridge and they'll be good for four days. Make sure the pan cools off first so you don't steam up the topping. Warm up in the microwave for a quick fix or gently reheat a whole pan under some foil so it stays moist and gooey.
Swap Ideas
No gouda or gruyere? Use Swiss or provolone for almost the same creamy bite. Want some tang? Toss a few crumbles of blue cheese in with your cheddar for a grown-up kick. Pasta shapes like penne or rotini grab the sauce just as well as elbows. Go with whole milk if you want a touch lighter, but still creamy.
Save Pin
How To Serve
This cheesy bake does double duty as both a main dish and a side. It's perfect next to smoky BBQ meats or a fresh green salad to cut the richness. Sometimes I’ll top it with a runny fried egg and tomatoes for a lux brunch. And at the holidays? It’s a star with roast chicken or ham.
Fun Facts & Background
Though mac and cheese has been around for centuries, it’s really taken off in America because anyone can put their spin on it. Using a bunch of different cheeses like in this dish shows just how much home cooks love adding their own touch to a comforting classic.
Common Questions
- → Which cheeses make everything extra gooey?
A mix of Velveeta, smoked gouda, smoked gruyere, colby jack, and extra sharp cheddar gives a stretchy, smooth sauce and big flavor.
- → Is it okay to swap out the pasta shape?
Definitely, you can grab rotini, penne, or fusilli instead of the usual elbows for a new twist.
- → How do I keep the noodles from turning too soft?
Cook the macaroni until it still has a bite left since it finishes getting tender in the oven. Boiling too long before baking makes it mushy.
- → What's the best way to stash leftovers?
Pop them in a covered container in your fridge for three days or less. Warm up in the microwave or oven until those cheeses melt again.
- → What's an easy way to prep this in advance?
Put it all together but don't bake, cover and keep in the fridge two days tops. Take it out so it's not super cold, then pop it in the oven as usual.
- → How can I boost the flavor even more?
Mix in a bit of cayenne or swap in more smoked cheese. You could even sprinkle buttered breadcrumbs over the top before baking for extra crunch.