Save Pin
The very first time I whipped up Hawaiian Roll French Toast, it was one of those slow, bright Sunday mornings. Sweet bread filled the air because my sister and I still had leftover King’s Hawaiian rolls from dinner. Neither of us wanted another boring turkey sandwich. A speedy fridge search later—eggs, milk, a bit of butter—and suddenly breakfast turned from leftovers to something amazing. Those soft rolls soaked up the eggy mixture, frying up with a crisp bite, and cozy vanilla-cinnamon smells hugged the whole kitchen. Comfort on a fork, honestly.
I stumbled onto this trick mostly out of boredom (really, wanting to dodge plain breakfast yet again). Now, I can’t imagine ever going back to basic bread. This goofy little dish just becomes a weekend staple: easy, a bit extra, and totally brings back memories of those mornings when you’d grab fresh treats at a bakery.
Must-Have Ingredients
- King’s Hawaiian rolls: Grab these pillowy sweet breads—day-old ones work best because they hold up after soaking. Pick the original kind for the soft touch and warm orange look.
- 4 large eggs: These hold the mix together. Choose eggs with nice shells and bright yolks for flavor.
- 1 cup milk: Whole milk brings a creamy vibe, but oat or 2% totally work. Fresh milk should never smell funky—always give it a quick sniff and shake.
- 1 tsp vanilla extract: Get good real vanilla if you can; it really makes the toast taste deeper and warmer.
- 1/4 tsp cinnamon: Sprinkle in ground cinnamon for warmth. Try tossing a little nutmeg or cardamom in for fun.
- Salt (pinch): Even just a little helps brighten up all the flavors. Kosher or sea salt mixes in smoothly.
- Butter for frying: Real butter gives you the tastiest golden crust. Go for unsalted if you want to tweak salt levels.
- Maple syrup to finish: Top with pure maple syrup—Grade A amber is a favorite. It’s that sweet touch tying it all together.
Simple Way to Make It
- Get Your Soak On:
- Beat up eggs with milk, vanilla, cinnamon, and salt till it’s nice and smooth—no streaks! This way, the bread gets a fair soak in all the goodness.
- Dip, Don’t Overdo:
- If you love crispy sides, slice rolls in half, or just keep them joined for tear-apart fun. Dunk each side quickly in the eggy mix—about 10 seconds per side so they’re moist but not falling apart. Too quick won’t be tasty; too long turns it to mush.
- Fry Butter-Side Down:
- Heat up your griddle or pan to medium-low. Melt some butter and let it foam up. Lay your custard-soaked rolls down, cut side first, giving each piece some breathing room. Fry 2–3 minutes per side, not touching them, so you get those lovely golden edges. Let them sit still for best results.
- Serve It Up:
- Heap the toast onto plates, offer extra butter, and drown them in syrup. You want a bite that’s toasty on the outside and has a warm, plush inside.
Save Pin
Top Highlights
You’ll get about 380–450 calories a serving—super filling for breakfast or brunch
Great way to bring sad, stale bread back to life and saves cash
No wild chef moves here—fun for kids, nearly goof-proof
My favorite hack: add a layer of sweet cream cheese and fresh berries inside the rolls before dipping. First time I stuffed them too much and lost a berry to the pan, but honestly, snacking on the runaway was almost as good as the finished thing.
Prep Ahead Tips
You can totally freeze these. Make and cook as usual, let them cool off, then pop into the freezer flat. Later, reheat in your toaster oven or oven so they come out hot and crispy. No sad soggy pieces in sight.
Creative Twists
Trade cinnamon for cardamom and add orange peel if you want holiday vibes. For a tropical hit, throw on toasted coconut and a splash of passionfruit syrup. Or, toss hot slices in cinnamon sugar for a churro-like treat.
Save Pin
Easy Seasonal Swaps
Come autumn, mix pumpkin puree and pumpkin spice in your batter. During those hot late summer days, try folding sliced peaches into the rolls before soaking—so good.
Favorite Tools
A big nonstick or trusty cast-iron pan makes flipping effortless. Cooking for a bunch? Use a wide electric griddle, and everyone gets to eat at once with nicely browned slices. A shallow wide bowl means every bit of bread gets coated without a mess.
Pro Tips
Try to use rolls that are about a day or two old—if they're too fresh, you’ll end up with mushy toast.
Hold each soaked roll above your bowl for a second to drip off any extra custard so you nail that creamy (but not soggy) inside.
Medium-low heat is perfect. Too hot and the outside burns fast while the inside stays raw. Stick to lower heat for the best golden, custardy results.
Even after dozens of lazy Saturday tries and taste tests, this French toast always disappears within minutes of hitting the table. It’s simple, comforting, and just about always gets asked for again!
Common Questions
- → What makes King’s Hawaiian rolls so good here?
These rolls stay super soft and have a hint of fruity sweetness, so the French toast ends up extra pillowy and tasty compared to using regular bread.
- → Will stale rolls still work out?
Actually, day-old rolls are spot on because they soak up all the eggy mix without going soggy, so you get a great texture.
- → Is there a best milk for this?
Go with whole milk for a really rich bite, but 2%, half-and-half, or even almond milk will get the job done, too.
- → Do I have to stick with real vanilla?
Real vanilla packs more taste and aroma, but if you’ve only got the fake stuff, toss it in—it’s still good, just a bit lighter.
- → What’s the best way to cook the rolls?
Cook them in melted butter over medium heat so both sides get that perfect golden crunch with lots of flavor.
- → Got ideas for toppings?
Pour on some maple syrup, toss on berries, or dust with powdered sugar—makes a sweet finish for breakfast or brunch.