Creamy Asiago Tortelloni Alfredo

The first time I cooked up Asiago Tortelloni Alfredo with grilled chicken, my kitchen completely changed. Melted butter and garlic filled the air, and the sound of chicken grilling made everything feel relaxed. It took me back to those calm, easy family dinners where sharing a meal just made the day better. This dish has so much creamy flavor, and it came together so fast. I honestly wish I'd tried it sooner—it's just pure comfort.

I learned how awesome it is to blend Asiago with Parmesan in Alfredo on a trip to Italy—it took the sauce from basic to next-level. Now, I always use these two together for the dream combo of tangy and smooth.

Irresistible Ingredients

• Minced garlic: Use fresh cloves for a punchy aroma—avoid the pre-chopped jars, the flavor's never as good
• Asiago and Parmesan cheeses (fresh grated): Skip the pre-bagged stuff—grated fresh cheese melts into a silky, shiny sauce
• Heavy cream or evaporated milk: Both work for a thick, creamy texture—cream is richer, evaporated milk is a bit lighter but still silky
• Boneless skinless chicken breasts: Go for ones that are plump and pale pink, and make sure they're even in thickness so they grill up just right
• Spices for chicken (kosher salt, black pepper, garlic powder, red chili flakes): These basics make grilled chicken super flavorful but don’t steal the spotlight
• Butter: Unsalted is best so you can tweak the saltiness—if you only have salted, just watch the seasoning
• Fresh tortelloni (cheese or chicken-stuffed): This is the main ingredient—fresh or good quality packaged is perfect, but make sure there's no dryness or cracked pasta

Step-by-Step Guide

Toss & Serve – The Best Part:

Mingle the pasta and rich sauce until every bite’s coated. Layer on sliced grilled chicken and finish everything with fresh parsley or chives for a bright finish.

Make That Asiago Alfredo – Creamy Goodness:

Melt butter gently, toss in the garlic and let it go soft (don’t burn it!). Pour in the cream and simmer so it thickens a bit. Remove from heat and blend in the grated cheeses, whisking so it’s silky and lump-free. Keep it on a warm—but off—burner so it doesn’t get thick or grainy before serving.

Boil the Tortelloni – Fluffy Pillow Pasta:

Get your water salty and bring it to a full boil. Drop in the tortelloni. Don't walk away—set a timer based on the label so it doesn’t turn mushy and fall apart later.

Grill That Chicken – Locked-In Flavor:

Rub chicken with oil and those spices. Heat up your grill or grill pan to a medium-high sizzle, and let the chicken cook without moving it to get a seared crust. Flip, cook through, and rest it before slicing to keep it juicy.

Save Pin

Top Highlights

• This packs 34g protein per portion, which keeps you full and energized
• Those tortelloni give you carbs for a steady mood—won’t weigh you down
• Two kinds of cheese mean a solid calcium boost for healthy bones
• It’s on the table in 25 minutes—total lifesaver for weeknights
• If you’re skipping meat, just leave out the chicken or toss in some spinach for a veggie version

I once accidentally grilled the chicken way too long—so dry! That mess-up got me to finally try a meat thermometer. Now, I always check temps and never end up with dry chicken again.

Tasty Twists & Seasonal Switch-Ups

• If you want more veggies, toss fresh spinach into the sauce with the tortelloni right before serving—easy extra greens
• Switch out chicken for some pan-fried shrimp for a fresh, protein-packed change
• Add sun-dried tomatoes or roasted red peppers, especially in late summer for extra zing and color
• When it’s chilly out, whisk in a dash of nutmeg to the sauce for a warm, cozy vibe

Save Time: Prep Ahead

Make the sauce a day early if you want, then rewarm it with a splash of cream or milk to get it smooth again. Cooked tortelloni should chill separately so it doesn’t get mushy. Chicken can hit the grill ahead of time too—just warm it up for about 10 minutes before serving so it stays juicy.

Handy Kitchen Gear

• A thick-bottomed saucepan helps keep your cheese and cream from burning
• To get the best sear, use a grill pan or greased outdoor grill for the chicken
• Grab a microplane or fine grater for the cheese so it melts quickly into the sauce

Pro Tips

1. Dry the chicken breasts with a paper towel before adding spices. That extra step gives you a browned, tasty crust instead of steamed chicken
2. Mix in cheese after turning the heat off to guarantee a creamy, shiny sauce with no lumps
3. Let grilled chicken kick back under foil for about 5 minutes—it’ll finish cooking gently and stay juicy when you cut it up

Save Pin

Common Questions

→ Which pasta pairs best with Asiago Alfredo sauce?

Cheese-filled tortellini or tortelloni work great since they soak up the creamy sauce nicely.

→ How do you keep grilled chicken juicy?

After cooking, cover the chicken loosely with foil and let it rest for about 5 minutes. That helps keep it tender and juicy.

→ Can I swap out Asiago cheese in the sauce?

Definitely. Parmesan is a good alternative to keep the cheesy flavor and creamy texture.

→ What’s a good way to thicken Alfredo sauce if needed?

Mixing in a little cornstarch or flour helps thicken the sauce, especially if you use a lighter cream.

→ How do you make sure chicken grills evenly for this dish?

Flattening chicken breasts to the same thickness before grilling makes them cook evenly and avoids dry spots.

→ Is there a vegetarian option for this dish?

You can skip the chicken and add extra cheese or veggies like spinach to keep it filling and tasty without meat.