Save Pin
Every time my oven beeps and I see this cheesy, bubbling tray come out, I feel like I've hit the jackpot. It all began one cold holiday when I stacked together five totally different cheeses—each one doing its own creamy or smoky thing. Everyone dove in before it even cooled off. From that day, I've always made this for family hangouts. It's been the highlight ever since.
Smoked Gouda and Gruyere? That combo was a happy snow day accident with my siblings. We played around with different cheeses until this dreamy combo made our classic mac honestly taste incredible. That little bit of smoke totally changed what I thought comfort food could be.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Kosher salt: Throws the best flavor into your pasta water. Grab a hearty, coarse salt brand for real taste.
- Egg: Acts as the glue, making your sauce nice and smooth once it's baked. Room temp eggs work best.
- Large elbow macaroni: Holds onto the cheese sauce perfectly; pick ones without cracks that look hearty.
- Evaporated milk or whole milk: Both make the sauce creamy. Evaporated is a bit thicker and lasts longer in your pantry, but whole milk is fine if that's what you have.
- Unsalted butter: Melts through the pasta, pulling everything together. Unsalted means you get to add just the right amount of salt later.
- Seasoned salt, onion powder, and granulated garlic: These three kick up the savory, umami flavor. Use fresh stuff—you’ll taste the difference.
- Paprika and ground mustard: Warm things up with a tangy bite. Try smoked paprika if you want even more depth.
- Black pepper and a pinch of cayenne if you like it spicy: These two cut the richness and keep things balanced. Fresh-cracked pepper works wonders.
- Ultimate five cheese mix:
- Velveeta or American cheese melts like magic for that silky texture
- Extra sharp cheddar brings the bold, iconic zing—shred it yourself for max meltiness
- Colby Jack adds gentle sweet undertones and melts smoothly
- Smoked Gruyere offers nutty aromas and real depth—go for a firm, fragrant slice
- Smoked Gouda introduces a toasted flavor—buy a wedge and grate it yourself
How to Cook It
- Prep Your Cheese:
- Fire up your oven at 350°F (177°C) and grease your baking dish. Put aside half a cup each of shredded cheddar, Colby Jack, smoked Gruyere, and smoked Gouda for the ultimate cheesy topping—it'll crisp up beautifully later.
- Pasta Moves:
- Get a big pot of salted water boiling. Toss in the elbows and give 'em a stir so they don't lump together. Cook until they're just firm, about ten minutes, then drain right away to stop them overcooking.
- Mix Milk and Spices:
- Whisk a beaten egg with your choice of milk, then throw in seasoned salt, onion powder, garlic, ground mustard, paprika, pepper, and a bit of cayenne if you’re in the mood for heat. Make sure there are no clumps—smooth and even is the goal.
- Pasta and Cheese Time:
- Back on the stove, melt that butter over medium until bubbly. Stir in the pasta so it's all slicked up. Pour in your milky, spicy mix. Fold it together. Then, pile in the main cheese blend, just mixing until it barely starts to melt and gets creamy (don't overdo it).
- Bake Away:
- Spoon everything into your waiting dish and smooth the top. Shower over the cheese you saved. Spray the inside of a foil piece with oil to stop sticking, then tuck the pan under it. Bake covered for 30 minutes, then take off the foil and keep going another 25-30 minutes. You're looking for bubbling cheese that's a little browned at the edges. Let it sit for 10 minutes before serving—that way, it'll keep its shape and the sauce stays thick and creamy.
I once cut in way too soon after baking—big mushy mess! That’s how I learned letting it chill for a bit makes it easier to scoop and slices come out super creamy. Want a little crunch? Toss some buttery toasted crumbs on before the last bake. Or switch up the smoked Gouda for an old Havarti—both are tasty swaps.
Prep Easy Ahead
Feel free to put the whole thing together and stash it in your fridge, covered tightly, for up to two days before baking. Give it a little time on the counter so it’s not ice-cold before it hits the oven. For longer storage, wrap the unbaked or baked dish up tight and freeze—unbaked lasts for two months, baked for six. When you want it, thaw it in the fridge overnight and warm it up gently.
Twist Up the Flavor
If you want something milder, swap out the smoked Gruyere and Gouda with provolone or Swiss. For a grown-up kick, mix blue cheese crumbles with your cheddar. Different noodles like penne or rotini hold on to the sauce differently—a fun way to shake things up. Craving more crunch? Top with crispy bacon bits or fried onions right before serving.
Handy Gear to Have
Use a tough cheese grater for smoother, better-melting cheese. A big, sturdy pot keeps pasta from sticking and cooks it evenly. Choose a quality glass or metal baking dish for a golden crust every time. Spritz foil with nonstick spray so cheese doesn’t stick when you peel it off later.
Insider Tricks
- Skip pre-shredded cheese—grate it yourself so it melts nice and smooth
- Let your mac rest 10 minutes after the oven for perfect slices
- Be generous with cheese on top for a bubbling, irresistible finish
This cheesy, five-blend mac is what I whip up for cozy nights or big family get-togethers. No matter how much I change things up, it also gets cheers when it comes out bubbling from the oven every single time.
Common Questions
- → What cheeses make it super creamy?
Mixing Velveeta, smoked gouda, sharp cheddar, colby jack, and smoked gruyere gives you that smooth, melty texture with bold flavor.
- → Can I use a different pasta shape?
Sure, penne, rotini, or fusilli work great too. They soak up the cheese sauce well and give a nice texture change.
- → How do I keep the pasta from getting mushy?
Cook the macaroni just until it’s tender but still firm before baking since it keeps cooking in the oven, so it doesn’t turn too soft.
- → What’s the best way to store leftovers?
Put any leftovers in a sealed container and pop it in the fridge for up to four days. Warm it up gently in the microwave or oven until hot and creamy again.
- → Can I make it ahead of time?
Yes, you can put it together in your casserole dish, cover it, and keep it in the fridge for up to two days. Let it warm up to room temperature before baking for best results.
- → Any tips for adding extra flavor?
Try a pinch of cayenne, use smoked cheeses, or sprinkle buttery breadcrumbs on top for some crunch and extra taste.