Save Pin
As soon as sage and pumpkin start to mix with gooey cheese, I get tossed right back to cool fall days with my folks. The whole thing started when I wanted something cozy but a little out of the ordinary on a cold October Saturday. Tossing creamy ricotta and smooth pumpkin puree in giant pasta shells wasn’t planned—just a happy fluke that forever changed a familiar Italian favorite into an autumn classic.
I was unsure the first time I mixed pumpkin into the cheesy filling. But after adjusting things a bit, I realized it didn’t just work—it made everything better. The soft, gentle sweetness with sage and warm nutmeg feels like autumn in every mouthful.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Mozzarella: Melts on top and goes golden and gooey—totally tempting
- Heavy cream: Makes the sauce extra smooth and blends pumpkin and tomato just right
- Rao’s Vodka Sauce: Jarred sauce that makes the work easy, with balanced tomato flavor and richness
- Nutmeg & fresh sage: Bring cozy spice and fresh herbal flavor—choose brightest sage for best flavor
- Egg: Holds everything together so the filling bakes up just right
- Fresh parmesan cheese: Tangy and sharp, freshly grated for loads of taste
- Pumpkin puree: Go for pure, unsweetened pumpkin to avoid extra sugar and taste that’s off
- Ricotta cheese: Creamy, dreamy texture—full-fat ricotta makes the filling extra rich
- Jumbo pasta shells: Make sure they’re sturdy and thick, so stuffing won’t bust them
Check your shells—they shouldn’t have splits or be too soft. Ricotta should look fresh—give it a little stir; it ought to be creamy, not runny. Pumpkin puree can taste wildly different from brand to brand, so pick one that tastes naturally earthy, not metallic or weirdly sweet.
How to Bring It All Together
- Finishing Touches in the Oven:
- Pour most of your velvety sauce across the dish, nestle in those stuffed shells, and pop it in the oven covered. Let the heat gently cook through—pull off the foil near the end so the cheese goes bubbly and golden on top.
- Mixing Up the Filling:
- Combine pumpkin, ricotta, egg, sage, garlic, nutmeg, parmesan, salt, and pepper until you get a silky, dreamy mix. Pumpkin keeps it moist, sage wakes things up, and the spices bring real warmth.
- Boiling and Cooling Your Shells:
- Boil those shells just enough to keep them sturdy. Lay them out in a single layer with olive oil so they stay soft and don’t clump together.
- Whipping Up the Sauce:
- Stir that vodka sauce, leftover pumpkin, and cream together until it’s rich and smooth—this ties all the flavors together and goes underneath the shells.
Save Pin
Once, when I tossed in rosemary instead of sage by accident, the flavors were way bolder and piney—a surprise that I totally dug. Turns out, this filling is tough enough for bigger, punchy herbs if you feel like experimenting.
Easy Prep Ideas
You can fill your shells the night before—just store them in the fridge uncovered, away from the sauce. That way they don’t get soggy and you’ll save time the next day, making this a lifesaver for busy nights or holidays.
Tasty Swaps
- Change out sage for thyme and toss in some chili flakes if you want a gentle spicy kick
- Add sautéed mushrooms or spinach to the filling for even more earthy flavor
- Go vegan by trading cheese for cashew cream and using your favorite plant-based shells
Handy Kitchen Tools
- Big pot, so your shells have room to move and don’t stick
- Wide baking dish—about 9x13—for lining up shells in a single, comfy layer
- Use a silicone spatula to stir your filling without making it flat
Smart Tips
- 1.
- Don’t cook your shells too long—al dente is what you want so they’re bendy but still hold up for stuffing.
- 2.
- Chop your sage at the last second to keep it super fragrant in the mix.
- 3.
- Let your shells cool before filling them or the cheese mixture will go runny and they could fall apart.
Save Pin
Common Questions
- → What type of pasta is used for this dish?
Big pasta shells are perfect since they can hold the creamy pumpkin and ricotta filling nice and snug.
- → How do I prevent the pasta shells from sticking?
Once drained, toss the shells in a bit of olive oil and spread them out on a baking tray to keep them from sticking before you fill them.
- → Can I prepare these stuffed shells in advance?
You sure can. Stuff the shells and keep them covered in the fridge for up to a day before baking. Just bake with sauce when you’re ready.
- → What flavors enhance the pumpkin filling?
Fresh sage, nutmeg, garlic powder, and parmesan cheese add gentle warmth and earthy notes that go so well with the pumpkin and ricotta mix.
- → How is the sauce prepared for baking?
Mix a jar of vodka sauce with pumpkin puree and a splash of cream. This makes a smooth, creamy sauce perfect for baking.
- → What baking steps ensure a golden cheese topping?
Cover and bake the shells for 30 minutes first. Then take off the foil, sprinkle mozzarella on top, and bake uncovered for 15 minutes till it’s all bubbly and golden.