Save Pin
Whenever I need to impress with dessert but don't want to fuss, I whip up this over-the-top, no-bake caramel toffee cheesecake. It's lusciously smooth from the cream cheese, packed with toffee chunks, and smothered in gooey caramel. Add a buttery cookie base and you've got my go-to crowd treat to cap off a big meal.
I first threw this together for an impromptu dinner. Everyone wanted seconds and hounded me for how to make it. Now it's what the family asks for every big event or birthday.
Heavenly Ingredients
- Crushed cookies for the bottom: These create that tasty crunchy base Pick digestive cookies for old-school flavor or grab ladyfingers for something softer
- Butter, melted: Binds the crumbs together and makes everything buttery Go for fresh butter—it really makes a difference
- Cream cheese: Main ingredient for a tangy, creamy bite Be sure it's at room temperature so the mixture is super smooth
- Powdered icing sugar: Sweetens things up and gives a soft finish Sifting it first helps the filling stay cloud-like
- Vanilla extract: Adds a cozy aroma Real vanilla is best if you've got it
- Heavy or whipping cream: Makes the filling so airy and rich High-fat cream helps keep things super creamy
- Toffee bits: Pops of sweet, crunchy caramel flavor Buy toffee chips or smash up some toffee bars yourself
- Gelatine: Makes sure your cheesecake keeps its shape Any kind is fine as long as you check the package for how to use it
- Milk: Just a splash to help the gelatine soften and blend in
- Caramel sauce: For drizzling all over the top Buy your favorite or make your own if you want to go all out
- Chopped chocolate caramel bars: For a bold finish and extra crunch Go for bars with gooey centers, they look great and taste even better
Simple Step-by-Step
- Get the Crumb Layer Ready:
- Use a blender or food processor to turn your cookies into fine crumbs. Stir melted butter through the crumbs until they feel like wet sand and are totally coated.
- Form the Base and Chill It:
- If your pan sticks, line it with parchment for easy removal. Dump in the buttery crumbs, push down evenly with a spoon, and chill in your fridge for no less than twenty minutes. This makes sure the base doesn’t fall apart.
- Beat Up the Cheesecake Mix:
- Grab a medium bowl and blend up the cream cheese, powdered sugar, and vanilla until it’s super smooth. Scrape down the sides as you mix—a smooth base makes all the difference.
- Whip That Cream:
- Whip the cold heavy cream in a separate bowl until really stiff peaks form. The stiff, airy whipped cream is what makes this dessert so cloud-like.
- Soften the Gelatine:
- Pour milk into a little pot, sprinkle in the gelatine, and give it a minute to absorb. Warm gently, constantly stirring, just until the gelatine dissolves—don’t let it boil.
- Mix in the Gelatine:
- Stir a couple of spoonfuls of your cream cheese mix into the warm gelatine to even out the temperature. Then gently fold that into the bulk of the cream cheese mixture so it’s all blended together.
- Fold With the Whipped Cream:
- Take your fluffy cream and gently fold in the cream cheese mixture. Use soft, sweeping motions to keep as much air in as possible. When that's even, toss in the toffee bits and give it one last fold.
- Layer and Chill:
- Scoop the creamy filling onto your cold crust and smooth out the top. Wrap up tightly and chill for at least four hours—overnight is even better. You want it firm and sliceable.
- Top and Dig In:
- Right before you serve, pour on a good amount of caramel sauce and scatter the chopped chocolate caramel bars over the top. Slice with a hot knife for the cleanest cuts and serve cold for the best texture.
Save Pin
The gooey toffee pieces are my absolute favorite and melt just right in the creamy filling. I even made this for my sister’s bridal shower and people went home stuffing my instructions into their bags after having seconds.
Storage Know-How
For leftovers, cover well and pop in the fridge for up to four days so the crust stays crisp and the filling doesn’t get soft. For longer storage, freeze slices on a tray until solid, then wrap up tight before moving them to a container. Let them thaw in the fridge overnight or until they’re soft enough for you to eat.
Swaps and Changes
If you’re out of digestive cookies, no worries—graham crackers or vanilla wafers work great for the base too. In a hurry? Whipped topping stands in nicely for cream. If you’d rather skip the gelatine, just chill the dessert for longer or freeze it a bit—it’ll be softer but still cuttable.
Save Pin
Serving Ideas
Pour on extra caramel and another handful of toffee bits to make it feel fancy. Fresh raspberries or strawberries on the side add a bright twist. It's super rich, so small pieces go a long way and you can serve quite a crowd.
Fun Backstory
Cheesecake goes all the way back to old-school Greece, but the version you don't bake became popular when people wanted quick, simple treats in America during the mid-1900s. The caramel and toffee add a delicious new layer that makes this dessert a great way to cap off any meal.
Common Questions
- → Is it okay to swap out the cookie for another kind at the bottom?
Absolutely! Graham crackers, ladyfingers, or even digestives all taste fab down there. Pick whatever you like best.
- → Will the filling still work without gelatine?
Gelatine gives you cleaner slices, but if you leave it out, you'll end up with a softer, super smooth middle. Pop it in the freezer for a bit to help it hold if it's too soft.
- → Best caramel sauce to grab?
Ready-made caramel saves you time, though homemade with sweetened condensed milk really makes it taste extra rich. Both totally work and taste awesome.
- → How long does this need to chill before it's set?
Give it at least 4 hours to firm up, but letting it sit overnight is even better. The layers hold together and the flavors get even yummier.
- → Can I use something besides toffee bits?
If you can't find toffee bits, just use chopped chocolate bars filled with caramel or regular chocolate squares instead to switch up the flavor.
- → How should I dress this up when serving?
Add broken up toffee or chocolate bars and a messy drizzle of caramel on top for major crunch and flavor. Do this right before eating so it's fresh.