Save Pin
The first time I threw together this Marry Me Chicken Soup was on a blustery Sunday, with rain clouds hanging overhead. I needed something cozy, like wrapping up in a blanket. The flavors pulled from Tuscan vibes—fresh basil, creamy goodness, those sun-dried tomatoes—reminding me of a friendly Italian café. But the chunky chicken and noodles made it pure comfort food. The house smelled fantastic, and soon this one landed a regular spot in my weeknight menu.
I came up with this flavor mashup by trying leftover rotisserie chicken with some sun-dried tomatoes I'd totally forgotten about in my pantry. Adding cream and basil took this whole thing from average to something you'd wanna celebrate, no joke.
Tasty Main Ingredients
- Heavy cream: brings that dreamy, smooth texture that balances out the tang
- Parmesan cheese: totally optional, but it gives a salty, nutty finish on top
- Italian seasoning, salt & pepper: gives everything a little lift and the right pop of flavor at the end
- Rotini pasta: those twisty shapes are built to catch sauce and taste even better when not overcooked
- Fresh basil: adds a punch of herby flavor; use basil that’s crisp and super green
- Chicken broth: the magic liquid base—go for homemade or unsalty store versions if you can
- Tomato paste: thickens up the soup and brings that rich, tomatoey backbone everyone loves
- Garlic: a total must-have for starting the flavor party; fresh is miles better
- Yellow onion: brings a little sweetness and ties lots of flavors together; skip the mushy ones
- Sun-dried tomatoes: they’re chewy, sweet, tangy, and bring extra flavor oomph—oil-packed? Even better
- Shredded chicken: your hands-down protein hero; using leftovers or rotisserie makes everything easier
When you buy the stuff, pick good broth and ultra-fresh herbs. Skip wilted basil and go easy on store-bought broths that taste too salty; it really does make a difference.
Easy Cooking Steps
- Silky Finish:
- Turn the burner off once the pasta's ready and swirl in the cream. This smooths everything out and brings all the flavors together.
- Get That Pasta Just Right:
- Put in the rotini and cook till it’s barely firm, then let it finish up in the hot soup so it never gets mushy. Timing’s everything.
- Richness Comes Together:
- Lower the heat and sprinkle in salt, cracked pepper, and those Italian herbs. Let things bubble away gently so the flavors settle in deep.
- Get Cozy With the Ingredients:
- Drop in your chicken and pour in the broth, turning up the heat to get things bubbling. Everything starts hanging out together, and suddenly your soup smells and tastes awesome.
- Layer on the Flavor:
- Add in those sun-dried tomatoes and a handful of basil. Let them sizzle with your onions and garlic for a bit. Mix in the tomato paste and give it a minute—brings out the sweetness and ties all the flavors up tight.
- Start With a Flavor Base:
- Let your onions and garlic cook until golden brown and softened—this is where all the best flavors start building up.
Grab a handful of parmesan for the top if you wanna get a little fancy and add a punch of salty goodness.
Save Pin
My personal favorite hack? I switched rotini for orzo once (left it in way too long), and it basically turned into a creamy risotto spin. It was the best happy accident and now I do it on purpose sometimes!
Make-Ahead Hacks
This soup keeps great in the fridge for three or four days and actually gets tastier by the next night. If you don't want soggy pasta, hold it back and add it at reheating. Freeze the soup without the cream and stir the cream in after thawing, so it stays silky.
Fun Twists
Instead of sun-dried tomatoes, try roasted red bell peppers for a mellow, smoky kick. A handful of kale or spinach tossed in at the end gives nice color and crunch. Want some spice? Red pepper flakes bring the heat.
Seasonal Switch-Ups
In summer, lighten things with Greek yogurt stirred in off the heat. If you have fresh cherry tomatoes, toss those in late summer for brightness. Winter’s all about tossing in mushrooms or roasted roots for extra coziness.
Favorite Kitchen Gear
A good heavy pot means nothing burns—even the cream. Garlic presses make things fast and bring out that fresh garlic flavor. And wooden spoons make mixing a breeze without messing up your pan.
Pro Tips to Nail It
- Cook onion and garlic slowly until they’re golden for that deep, layered taste
- Let that tomato paste fry with your veggies for a whole minute before adding broth—it turns sweet and rich
- Always pour in the cream after turning the heat off so it stays smooth, then adjust salt and pepper at the end to taste
Save Pin
Common Questions
- → What type of pasta works best here?
Rotini pasta works great since it holds the creamy sauce nicely. You could swap in penne or fusilli if you like.
- → Can I use fresh tomatoes instead of sun-dried?
You can use fresh tomatoes, but sun-dried ones bring extra sweetness and richer flavor to the sauce.
- → How do I prevent the pasta from overcooking in the soup?
Follow the package instructions for pasta and watch it closely. Adding pasta near the end of the cooking will keep it just right.
- → Is it necessary to use heavy cream?
Heavy cream gives a nice creamy feel, but half-and-half or dairy-free cream can work if you want it lighter or different.
- → What cheese pairs well as a garnish?
Grated parmesan is perfect on top, giving a salty, nutty touch that goes well with the creamy sauce.