Delicious Cheesesteak Tortellini

Whenever ribeye sizzles on a hot pan, I’m tossed right back to those lively Friday nights with friends crowding the kitchen—everyone waiting for something hearty and cheesy. That’s actually how this Cheesesteak Tortellini with Creamy Provolone Sauce came about. It combines the bold taste of Philly steak with laid-back pasta vibes, so every forkful is its own little party.

I never thought swapping a hoagie roll for pasta would be so awesome, but tossing steak and peppers in a dairy-rich sauce took weeknight dinners up a notch. Once I figured out provolone melts so easily into cream, even pals who avoid heavier sauces started going for seconds.

Irresistible Ingredients

• Beef (sirloin or ribeye): juicy slices full of flavor—go for nicely marbled pieces for extra tenderness
• Tortellini (cheese-filled): soft pasta stuffed with cheese; fresh or frozen both work
• Olive oil: grabs that golden crust on steak and lets flavors shine through
• Green bell pepper and onion: bring in some crunch and a gentle sweetness; look for firm, shiny veggies
• Garlic: adds a warm kick—choose nice full cloves
• Beef stock: makes the sauce heartier; homemade or good store-bought does the job
• Dash of Worcestershire: kicks up the tangy, savory notes
• Italian herbs: a mix that brightens everything up—fresh or dried is cool
• Cream (heavy): brings hug-level richness, so use the full-fat stuff for the best texture
• Provolone (shredded): the melty superstar—grab a block and shred it yourself
• Salt and pepper: just the basic flavor boosters
• Red pepper flakes (if you want): sneak in some heat if that’s your style
• Handful of chopped parsley: for a splash of color and a bit of fresh flavor at the end

Shopping tips: For the steak, you want a nice rosy color and thin streaks of fat. If it's pre-sliced, make sure it’s got plenty of time till the sell-by date and feels cool and moist. Skip already-shredded provolone—do it yourself just before cooking so your sauce stays smooth.

Getting Started – Steak Sear

Getting Started – Steak Sear:

Use hot olive oil in your pan to brown the steak fast and lock in flavor. Give the pieces space; crowding them will just make the meat steam, not sear. Work with smaller batches if you need.

Veggie Time – Tender and Sweet

Veggie Time – Tender and Sweet:

Toss your bell pepper and onion in the skillet first and let them go until they’re soft and see-through—their sugars come out, balancing everything. Toss the garlic in right at the end so it gets fragrant but doesn’t burn.

Sauce Magic – Building Flavor

Sauce Magic – Building Flavor:

Add a splash of beef broth and Worcestershire to scrape up all those tasty browned bits (called fond), which gives your sauce serious umami. Stir in provolone with heavy cream on gentle heat until it’s silky and ready to stick to all the good stuff.

Finish Line – Bringing it All Together

Finish Line – Bringing it All Together:

Drop the steak, veggies, and cooked tortellini into the sauce so everything soaks up flavor. Let it bubble just long enough for everything to come together without cooking the pasta too much.

Save Pin

The first time I chucked a handful of cheese in all at once, it turned into a weird sticky blob—now I always let the pan cool a little and sprinkle in cheese in stages. Smooth and creamy, every single time. Learned that the hard way, but hey, it works.

Prep Ahead Tips

Leftovers reheat like a charm. Make the steak and sauce ahead, cook tortellini fresh and toss everything together when you’re ready to eat so the pasta stays soft. If things dry out, just splash in a little broth or cream when you warm it up.

Fun Flavor Switch-Ups

Swap in mushrooms or sweet caramelized onions instead of peppers if that’s your thing. Want a smoky hit? Add a pinch of smoked paprika to the sauce. And you can use other melt-friendly cheeses like fontina or mozzarella for a lighter taste.

Tools I Trust

Grab a heavy pan so the heat stays steady—this keeps your sauce silky instead of scorched. A sharp knife keeps steak and veggies thin and even, which speeds up cooking and keeps everything safe and easy.

Little Tricks

• Get steak nice and dry before searing so it browns instead of steaming.
• Add provolone slowly off the burner to skip any annoying cheese lumps.
• Save some pasta cooking water—you can use it to thin the sauce and help it stick better thanks to the starch.

Save Pin

Common Questions

→ Which beef cut is best for this?

Ribeye or sirloin slices work great because they cook fast and stay tender while bringing rich flavor.

→ How do I keep the sauce from getting too thick?

Save some pasta water and add a bit at a time to keep the sauce smooth and creamy without getting too heavy.

→ Can I add some spice without ruining the flavor?

A small amount of red pepper flakes gives a nice gentle heat that goes well with the creamy sauce.

→ What herbs make this taste better?

Italian seasoning adds earthiness to the sauce and fresh parsley on top brings a bright, fresh note.

→ Should I drain the pasta fully?

It’s important to drain but keep some pasta water to adjust the sauce so it clings perfectly to the pasta.