Save Pin
Nothing smells better than onions, garlic, and ground beef sizzling away together. That smell? It always reminds me of laid-back afternoons as a kid hanging out with my mom. Whenever folks dropped in out of nowhere, she’d toss together these oozy beef and cheese sandwiches. Honestly, it fed a houseful fast—and everyone always wanted seconds. Total comfort food, every single time.
I loved how straightforward this dish was when I first saw it—you pretty much just brown ground beef in the pan, then mix in everything and pack it into toasted bread. Ages ago I found out that mixing cheddar right into the pan with the beef keeps the cheese smooth and melty. It never fails to wow.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Ground beef (1 lb): go with 80/20 blend for juicy bites; pour off extra grease so it’s not too oily
- Cheddar cheese (1–2 cups grated): choose sharp for bolder taste or mild if that’s your thing; grate your own for the dreamiest melt
- Avocado oil (2 tbsp): good for frying since it stands up to high heat and doesn’t add weird flavors
- Garlic (1 clove minced): get that punchy, fresh boost by using a real clove, not powder
- Montreal Steak Spice (2 tsp): all the herby/peppery goodness in one shake; look for low-salt if you want to dial it back
- Onion (1 small, finely chopped): sweetens things up—pick ones that feel heavy, with papery skins
- Worcestershire sauce (2 tsp): tiny splash, huge flavor—cheap and always worth it
- Green bell pepper (1 finely chopped): a little bite and crunch—grab ones that look shiny and bright
- Cream of mushroom soup (1¼ cup): gives that thick, creamy feel; can make your own if you’re feeling fancy, or grab low-sodium cans
When you’re shopping, pick veggies that feel weighty for their size and scan soup cans for weird buildups or extras you might not want.
Easy Prep Steps
- Sauté to Build Layers:
- Heat your avocado oil, then toss in beef and onions. Give the pan time—get that beef dark golden and onions soft, so their flavors get cozy. Sprinkle in Montreal Steak Spice right now, so the meat really soaks it up.
- Mix In Freshness and Zing:
- Now add garlic and green bell pepper. Cook this for just a few so the peppers stay a little crisp, and let the garlic fill the kitchen with its magic aroma.
- Make It Rich and Creamy:
- Pour in cream of mushroom soup and drizzle with Worcestershire. Turn down the heat and let it all bubble gently so it thickens up and everything tastes like one big, gooey team.
- Cheese Goes in Last:
- Turn off the heat—fold that cheddar right in and mix it until everything goes all stretchy and smooth.
- Time to Fill the Buns:
- Grab your toasty hoagie rolls and stuff them with heaps of the hot, cheesy beef. Serve while everything’s gooey and grab napkins.
Save Pin
Top Perks
- Each serving gives you about 20g of protein, so it’ll really keep you full
- Done in around 25 minutes—perfect for those nights when you’re in a rush
- Tastes like a big warm hug and never lets a hungry crew down
One time I totally spaced and forgot to drain the beef, so things got way too greasy. Take it from me: go for leaner beef or just drain it and you’ll avoid soggy bread. For a wild twist, throw in a dash of sriracha at the end—spicy, and so addictive! That one’s a keeper.
Prep-Ahead Tips
You can totally make the beef mix the night before and stash it in the fridge. Just heat it up gently when you’re ready, so you only have to toast your bread and serve. Makes party hosting way less stressful.
Flavor Switch-Ups
If you’re bored of cheddar, try pepper jack or mozzarella for a fresh cheese vibe. Adding cooked onions or mushrooms to the mix packs in even more umami. Want it meatless? Grab one of those plant-based ground meats and use a mushroom sauce for that deep flavor.
Seasonal Spins
When summer’s wrapping up, roasted red peppers work great in place of green ones. In winter, shake in a bit of smoked paprika or even a touch of cinnamon to really warm things up.
Favorite Tools
Grab a tough skillet with a lid so the beef mix stays warm while you fix buns. Box graters are clutch for melty cheese. Silicone spatulas work way better than wooden ones when you’re mixing cheese in—they don’t stick!
Insider Tricks
- 1.
- Let the beef brown long enough—even if you’re impatient. That’s where big flavor happens.
- 2.
- Add cheese after you’ve turned off the burner for the creamiest finish.
- 3.
- If it ever comes out super stiff, splash in a little milk ’til it loosens up so every mouthful is smooth.
Save Pin
Common Questions
- → Which beef cut is best here?
Ground beef with about 20% fat keeps things juicy and flavorful for the filling.
- → Can I swap out the cream of mushroom soup?
Definitely. You can use canned or homemade cream soups like cream of chicken to keep that creamy feel.
- → How do I stop the filling from drying out?
After cooking, drain extra fat and stir in a splash of milk if it feels too thick or dry.
- → What cheese makes this taste best?
Sharp cheddar melts right in and adds a punch of tang that pairs great with the beef and sauce.
- → Can I put in something spicy?
For some heat, mix in sriracha or any hot sauce you like to give it a nice kick.