Save Pin
Every time Tony whips up these mushrooms, they fill the room with cozy vibes and a deep, buttery taste. Super easy, they turn a basic ingredient into a rich side or tasty topper for burgers, toast, anything really. When I need something quick that'll wow, mushrooms and garlic are my go-to move.
The first time I made these, a bunch of friends showed up out of the blue and I needed a fast fix. Ever since, they always check if Tony’s mushrooms are happening that night.
Fresh Ingredients List
- Kosher salt: Big flakes let you hit the right seasoning balance. Don’t overdo it for best results.
- Lemon juice: Squeezing a fresh lemon at the end wakes up every bite. Emphasizes brightness.
- Extra virgin olive oil: Helps get everything golden, adds smoothness—use your fanciest bottle if you have it.
- Flour: Just a light sprinkle thickens up that sauce. If you can’t do gluten, pour in a bit more wine and skip the flour.
- Wine: White, Marsala, even red—whatever you’d drink works here. It makes everything deep and a little fancy.
- Black pepper: Cracked fresh is best for some mellow heat and warmth.
- Fresh garlic: Go for several big cloves, chopped very fine so every bite pops with flavor. Aim for firm, juicy bulbs.
- Fresh mushrooms: Grab crimini or white buttons and slice them a quarter-inch thick so they cook up nice and even. Pick ones that look dry and firm—skip any with soggy spots.
Delicious Step-by-Step Instructions
- Make the wine sauce:
- Pour in your pick of wine. Watch the liquid fizz and bubble up, then stir to coat the mushrooms. After a minute or two, you’ll see the glossy sauce grab onto every slice. All the flavors come together now.
- Thicken it up:
- Dust the mushrooms lightly with flour, stirring for a good minute. You want the flour to vanish into the pan and cling to the mushrooms. You’ll spot a thin layer starting to form—that’s what gives you a richer bite.
- Boost with lemon and seasoning:
- Hit the pan with lemon juice and plenty of salt and pepper. Stir it up so every mushroom soaks up that citrusy kiss and salt spreads through. Looks dry at first, but soon the pan fills with awesome juices.
- Brown the mushrooms:
- Add your sliced mushrooms to the pan and stir so they’re all shiny with oil. Let them soften for a few minutes. This lets each piece really catch all the garlicky oil goodness.
- Sizzle the garlic and oil:
- Start by heating olive oil with your minced garlic in a skillet over medium-high. Stir while it sizzles, making sure garlic doesn’t stick or burn. Right away, you’ll smell those amazing garlicky notes.
Save Pin
Best part for me? When I crack open the wine for the sauce and the whole room smells incredible. This was the first dish my son got the hang of alone. Now he always doubles the garlic just like dad.
How to Store
Leftovers go in a sealed container and chill happily in the fridge for up to three days. To reheat, toss them back in a skillet with a splash of water or broth so the sauce loosens up again. Microwaving? Try to skip it since it can make the mushrooms soggy.
Swaps and Shortcuts
No vermouth? Use white wine or some veggie broth. Craving more herby flavor, sprinkle in chopped parsley or thyme before serving. If dairy’s not your thing, use vegan butter for some of the oil.
Ways to Serve
Spoon big helpings on creamy polenta, load them onto grilled steak, or add to a toasty slice of sourdough. Fold into your eggs for a next-level breakfast. They're perfect with roast chicken too.
Save Pin
Background and Traditions
Pans of sautéed mushrooms like these show up in every French and Italian bistro. This simple way of browning mushrooms with olive oil and finishing with wine helps their natural flavor stand out. You’ll see them in everything from appetizers to main dishes.
Common Questions
- → Which mushrooms should I use here?
Baby bella, cremini, or plain white button mushrooms all soak up the flavors and cook up nice and golden.
- → Do I really need flour?
Nope, it’s totally up to you. Flour makes a thicker sauce, but skip it if you’d rather keep things lighter or gluten-free.
- → What wines taste good in this?
Dry red, Marsala, or even a splash of vermouth work great. Each one changes up the flavor just a bit—so go with what you’ve got or what you like.
- → How do you serve these?
Pile them over mashed potatoes, put them on rice, spoon them onto steak, chicken, or even crunchy toast. Super flexible.
- → Is it cool to make them earlier in the day?
Definitely—make them ahead, stash in the fridge, and warm them up gently later. They'll still taste awesome and the texture holds up.