Save Pin
These cheesy garlic meatloaf muffins are our weeknight superstar. You get all those cozy Italian-American vibes, with way less hassle. Shaping them in muffin cups means lightning-fast portions and, once you add gooey mozzarella and a nice spoonful of marinara, it's pure comfort. They come together in a flash, but taste like you fussed for hours.
The first time I made these for a game night, they vanished before anyone sat down to play. Now my kids keep asking for them every pizza night, mostly thanks to the cheesy top.
Tasty Ingredients
- Parmesan cheese: brings salty, bold flavor into every bite. Freshly grated from a block is best for both melting and taste
- Ground chicken: a mild and lean meat, perfect for picking up all the seasoning. Choose chicken that looks fresh and pink for the tastiest results
- Breadcrumbs: help hold everything together. Go plain or make your own crumbs to tweak the flavors
- Egg: helps the loaves keep their shape and not crumble apart
- Milk: adds moisture, keeping things tender. Whole milk works best if you want it extra soft
- Salt and pepper: bring out every other flavor in the mix. Season and taste to dial in what's right for you
- Onion powder: adds subtle sweet notes throughout the loaf. Give it a whiff to make sure it's still fresh
- Dried oregano: gives that unmistakable Italian aroma. Check your jar isn't stale for the full punch
- Garlic cloves: make the flavor pop. Use nice plump cloves and mince at the last minute
- Fresh parsley: makes each loaf look and taste lively. Chop just before mixing for the brightest result
- Marinara sauce: the finishing touch, bringing tang and zip on top. Pick a sugar-free jar or whip up your own
- Mozzarella cheese: over the top, it bubbles and browns for a melty finish. Whole milk mozz has the richest melt
Step-by-Step Directions
- Add Toppings and Melt:
- Spoon marinara sauce right on top of each hot loaf, toss a bit of mozzarella over, then bake another five minutes so the cheese melts and turns golden
- Bake It Up:
- Cook in your oven for about 20–25 minutes, or until the tops look nice and golden. If you're unsure, a thermometer stuck in the center should hit 165°F and the juices should run clear
- Fill and Shape:
- Pack the blended mix into the muffin cups, smoothing out the tops. Use your spoon or hands for this—make sure they're packed in so the shape holds while baking
- Mix All Your Base:
- In your big mixing bowl, throw in the chicken, parmesan, and breadcrumbs. Toss in parsley, dry oregano, onion powder, salt, pepper, then add the minced garlic, crack in that egg, and pour in the milk. Get in there with clean hands or a fork—mix gently, and stop once everything sticks together but don’t overdo it or you’ll end up with tough loaves
- Preheat and Prep:
- Turn your oven to 375°F and grease a muffin pan with a spritz of oil or a brush of butter. That way, nothing sticks and clean up is a snap
Save Pin
Extra fresh garlic makes the whole place smell just like grandma's kitchen on Sunday. I save a couple meatloaves for my husband's sandwiches—he gets so excited when he finds one in his lunch.
Storage Advice
When they're cool, pop the mini loaves right out of the muffin tin and store them in a food container for up to four days in the fridge. To freeze, wrap each one in foil and drop into a freezer bag. Thaw in the fridge overnight and then warm in the oven if you want them juicy and not dry.
Swaps and Alternatives
Ground turkey or beef will both work if you don't have chicken. If you need gluten free, just use gluten free crumbs. Can't do dairy? Pick oat milk and dairy-free cheese. If you want a new flavor, switch oregano for Italian herbs or basil, or even throw in some chopped sun dried tomatoes.
Save Pin
How to Serve
Set these little loaves next to some garlicky noodles, steamed greens, or a Caesar salad. For a fun lunch, slice a loaf in half and pop into a slider bun—kids love that. Leftovers taste awesome with roasted veggies, too.
Tradition and Inspiration
Turning traditional meatloaf into these cute muffin cups gives a playful twist on old-school Italian-American comfort. The marinara and cheesy topping bring all the flavor of chicken parm, just easier and faster. It’s a new way to share those classic family table memories with a fresh spin.
Common Questions
- → Can I swap in ground turkey for chicken?
You bet—ground turkey works just as well and keeps everything moist and tasty.
- → How do I keep my meatloaves from drying out?
Don't overbake and try not to mix the meat too much. Adding milk, an egg, and parmesan helps them stay nice and juicy.
- → Is it possible to prep these in advance?
Definitely. Mix and form everything in your muffin pan, then chill them in the fridge until it's time to bake.
- → What goes well alongside these loaves?
Try them with creamy mashed potatoes, roasted veggies, or a simple bowl of pasta for a cozy meal.
- → Can these mini meatloaves be frozen?
For sure. Just bake them, cool them completely, and stash in a sealed container in the freezer. Warm them up when you want to eat and they'll taste great.