Mouthwatering Patty Melt Sandwich

If your stomach is growling and you're stumped for dinner ideas, a patty melt with bubbly cheese, crisp buttery bread, and juicy beef always hits the spot. My family even asks for it when nothing else sounds right—even the picky ones clean their plates.

I wasn’t sure about it at first—how could something so basic taste this good? Then it quickly became a family favorite whenever we wanted a cozy, old-school diner meal.

Tasty Ingredients

• Provolone cheese: Melts like a dream for gooey, creamy goodness in each bite
• Cheddar cheese: Sharp real cheddar gives a rich, tangy kick—avoid rubbery singles if you can
• White sugar: Tiny bit balances out the tang in the sauce
• Sweet relish: Tosses in tang and a bit of sweet crunch to the sauce
• Real bacon bits: Crunchy and smoky—don’t use fake bits if possible
• Ketchup: Brings mild sweetness and rounds out the flavors
• Mayonnaise: Makes the sauce nice and creamy; full-fat is best for rich texture
• Onion powder: Gives mellow onion flavor without being harsh; make sure it’s fragrant, not stale
• Sea salt: Brightens things up and helps meld all the flavors together—fine salt mixes in fast
• Ground black pepper: Warm, peppery bite; using fresh-cracked really boosts flavor
• Ground beef: 80/20 is perfect for juicy, tender patties; go with fresh if you can
• Butter: Spreadable, not melting, butter makes the bread crisp and golden; the tastier the butter, the better the sandwich
• Rye bread: Thick, sturdy slices hold up under all that melty cheese and beef; the tangy bread adds a lot of flavor

Simple Step-by-Step Directions

Toast and Serve:

After assembling, lay sandwiches in the skillet for two or three minutes per side until both sides are golden and cheesy. Do this for all sandwiches. Serve hot right away!

Add Sauce and Top Bread:

Slather sauce over the bare side of your last bread slice. Pop it on top, sauce-side down, then press down gently to help everything come together.

Assemble the Melts:

Heat a new skillet over medium-low. Place the buttered side of bread down, spread cheddar and provolone on first, then lay on the warm beef patties.

Make Your Sauce:

As the meat finishes, grab a bowl and whisk together mayo, ketchup, sugar, relish, and bacon bits. Stir until you’ve got a creamy sauce with bacon bits sprinkled throughout—set it close by.

Check Temperature:

Push a meat thermometer into the center of a patty—you're looking for 160°F, which means the beef is cooked and good to go.

Cook the Patties:

Fire up a skillet on medium-high. Toss in the formed beef patties and let them sizzle untouched for three minutes, then flip and cook three more. Lower the heat to finish cooking through for around five minutes until it's no longer pink in the middle.

Mix and Shape the Beef:

Put ground beef, salt, black pepper, and onion powder in a bowl. Use your hands to mix just until combined—overmixing makes tough patties. Shape into three patties that fit your bread slices.

Prep the Bread:

Grab your rye bread and spread a thick layer of butter on one side of each. Lay them flat while you get ready for the next steps.

Save Pin

Every time I eat a patty melt, it takes me back to Friday nights at a roadside diner with my dad—a hot, crispy sandwich and ice-cold soda after a long week. Brings back all the best memories.

Smart Storage

Once done, let leftovers cool, wrap them snug in foil, and stash them in the fridge. Eat within two days for best flavor. Reheat slowly in a skillet so you get crispy bread again and gooey cheese in the middle. You can pop it in the microwave to warm it, but the crunch won’t come back.

Swaps and Options

Don’t have rye? Sourdough or solid white sandwich bread will work too—just brings a milder taste. Use Monterey Jack or Swiss if you’re out of cheddar and provolone. You can even switch up the relish for pickles or some diced onions if that’s what you have.

Fun Ways to Serve

Pile pickles and kettle chips alongside for a real diner vibe. Or try tossing together a green salad or some crunchy coleslaw. If you want something heartier, bake some oven fries or roast sweet potatoes on the side.

Save Pin

Quick Patty Melt Backstory

The patty melt made its mark in American diners sometime after the 1950s, probably inspired by folks craving something between a hamburger and a grilled cheese. It quickly became a feel-good staple that’s stuck around because it’s both familiar and just a bit different from your usual burger.

Common Questions

→ Which bread works best when making a patty melt?

Go for rye bread. It’s got a great crunch and unique taste, and it stands up nicely to all that cheesy, meaty goodness on the grill.

→ How can I stop my beef patty from falling apart when I flip it?

Let the patties cook without poking them for a few minutes first. Gently scoop them up with a big, flat spatula so they hold together.

→ What cheeses taste awesome in a patty melt?

Cheddar gives you a sharp kick, while Provolone melts so smooth. Together, they balance out for seriously tasty bites.

→ What’s a good way to tell if the meat’s cooked all the way?

Stick a food thermometer in and look for at least 160°F (71°C). That way, you know it’s totally cooked through.

→ Is it cool to switch up the toppings or add stuff?

Try tossing in caramelized onions or a swipe of mustard. Feel free to swap in your favorite sauces or anything else you love.