Save Pin
When you're craving restaurant comfort at home, nothing hits the spot like Texas Roadhouse Smothered Chicken loaded with melty jack cheese. That gooey cheese with juicy chicken makes everyone happy, and it comes together with stuff you probably already have in your kitchen.
After one taste my whole crew was hooked, and now my littlest one has dubbed this 'cheese chicken night.' It’s a quick family favorite we all look forward to and feels a bit special for a weeknight.
Delicious Ingredients
- Low sodium chicken broth: makes the sauce nicely savory but not salty Use a homemade batch or grab a good store brand
- Fresh garlic: punches up flavor with a little zip Select bulbs with tight skin and skip any with green stems
- Heavy cream: the secret to a super luxe sauce Make sure it’s cold and shake the carton before pouring
- Paprika: adds gentle heat and pretty color Sweet paprika is your best bet and it’s always easy to find
- Boneless skinless chicken breasts: quick cooking and turn out juicy if you don’t let them go too long Try pasture raised if you can—they’re so flavorful
- Shredded jack cheese: melts smooth and gives the dish a mild bite If you have the time to shred a block, it melts even better than pre-shredded
- Salt and pepper: these bring every other flavor alive Freshly cracked pepper gives extra zing, so sample and adjust
- Unsalted butter: for browning and you get to control the saltiness Splurge on the good stuff if you want super flavor
Easy Step-by-Step
- Finish & Serve:
- Let it sit for about five minutes uncovered after you take it from the oven, so all the flavor settles in and the chicken stays nice and moist
- Melt Cheese and Bake:
- Turn off the stove, tuck your chicken pieces into the sauce, cover them up with shredded jack cheese, and pop all that into the oven. Bake open for 20–25 minutes till you’ve got bubbling golden cheese
- Make the Sauce:
- Pour in the cream and broth, let it simmer, and use a spoon to scrape up any brown bits—they boost your sauce flavor big time Let it cook for around a minute to thicken a bit
- Get the Flavors Going:
- Drop in the garlic and shake in the paprika Cook and stir for about a minute Give the garlic a sniff—you’ll know it’s ready when you get that sweet smoky smell
- Sear the Chicken:
- Add chicken breast in a layer, sprinkle on salt and pepper, and brown each side in melted butter over medium heat. Go about 6 minutes a side so you get some color and the chicken holds the juices in
- Start the Oven & Prep Your Pan:
- Kick your oven to 375°F and lightly grease a baking dish so nothing sticks
Save Pin
The jack cheese absolutely makes this dish for me. I once swapped in some cheddar, but jack melts smoother and just brings those southern family dinner vibes—I remember everyone fighting for the cheesiest piece!
Storage Advice
Stash any extras in a sealed container in your fridge for up to three days. For reheating, go low and slow in a 300 degree oven or gently on the stove with a bit of broth or cream to loosen the sauce again. The sauce firms up as it cools and makes the leftovers extra rich.
Swaps You Can Make
No jack cheese? Use mozzarella or provolone for something milder, or pepper jack if you want a little kick. Lighten things up by swapping half and half for the cream, but expect a thinner sauce. Chicken thighs work too—just give them a bit more baking time for juicy results.
Serving Ideas
This goes great on a pile of mashed potatoes, over buttered rice, or with thick bread to mop up the sauce. Round things out with bright green beans or broccoli for color and balance, or make it a meal for company with a crunchy side salad.
Save Pin
History and Background
This meal comes from old-school southern comfort food. Smothered chicken was always about using simple ingredients and turning them into real soul food. With jack cheese, you get a taste of that Texas Southwest spin too, making it a hit all over.
Common Questions
- → Is it fine to swap out jack cheese for something else?
Totally fine! Monterey Jack melts like a dream, but cheddar or mozzarella can step in and still give you that creamy, cheesy top.
- → What should I eat with smothered chicken?
Stuff like mashed potatoes, fresh green beans, or a pile of sautéed spinach are great with this creamy, tasty dish.
- → Could I make this meal ahead?
For sure! Sear the chicken, put everything together in the pan ahead of time, then bake when you're ready for the best results.
- → How do I stop the chicken from getting dry?
Letting it simmer in the cream and broth then throwing cheese on top keeps it juicy. Just don't leave it in the oven too long.
- → Can I make a lighter version?
Try swapping heavy cream for half-and-half and use lower-fat cheese instead. Still tastes good and feels lighter.