Save Pin
Biting into a hot golden fried sandwich stuffed with creamy cheesecake filling and sweet berries is pure bliss. These Fried Strawberry Cheesecake Sandwiches quickly became our go-to in my house. They’re a hit whether you want a showy brunch, an easy breakfast, or a fun treat after dinner with friends.
My kids instantly made this a Sunday favorite after their first taste. Anytime we’re looking for an excuse to make something playful that brings everyone together, these fried sandwiches are our pick.
Tasty Ingredients
- Butter: Real unsalted butter gives you that perfect golden crispy outside. Frying with butter makes all the difference.
- Milk: Full fat milk gives your batter extra richness, but any kind does the trick.
- Large eggs: Eggs make the bread stick together and help form a custardy coating when you fry it.
- Strawberry jam: Amp up berry flavor with a good high-fruit jam. It adds sweetness and helps keep the filling together.
- Fresh strawberries: The riper and juicier your berries, the more delicious and colorful your sandwiches will be.
- Powdered sugar: This one is for a silky bite and dusting over the top right before serving.
- Cream cheese: Soften it first so your filling comes out super smooth—go for full-fat if you want it extra creamy.
- Brioche or challah bread: The bread should be soft and slightly sweet. Get a bakery loaf if you want these to taste super special.
Simple Step Guide
- Finish and Plate
- Set fried sandwiches on a plate with paper towels to soak up extra butter. Give them a heavy dusting of powdered sugar and enjoy while they're still warm.
- Get Frying
- Pop some butter into a big skillet and heat over medium. Once you see it bubble and smell that buttery aroma, gently lay in your sandwiches. Don’t stack too many in the pan at once. Cook about two or three minutes on each side till they’re crisp and deep gold. If they brown too fast, turn down the heat a bit.
- Dip Time
- Dip each stuffed sandwich into your egg and milk mix, making sure both sides get covered. Let the extra coating drip off before heading to the skillet.
- Egg Mix Prep
- In a shallow bowl, whisk together eggs and milk till combined. You want enough liquid to dip each sandwich all the way.
- Sandwich Setup
- Spread that creamy cheese filling thickly on four slices of bread. Gently layer the strawberries on top. Spoon over some strawberry jam and spread—but don’t go crazy or the filling will ooze out when frying. Add the top slice of bread and press gently.
- Cream Cheese Prep
- Stir softened cream cheese and powdered sugar together till totally smooth in a small bowl. Scrape the bowl and get rid of any lumps. This filling should feel super creamy to go with the fruit.
Save Pin
Picking strawberries is always my favorite step. The time my niece helped at the farmer’s market—she was so proud to find the ripest red berries. That moment makes the whole thing extra sweet for me.
Tips for Leftovers
Store cooled sandwiches in a sealed container in the fridge and they’ll keep up to two days. For the crunchiest results, warm them back up in a skillet over low for three to four minutes per side. You can even freeze them individually wrapped for a month. Heat from frozen in your oven or air fryer till they’re hot inside.
Swaps and Alternatives
No strawberry jam? Try using apricot or raspberry for a twist. Mascarpone or whipped ricotta work great if you want a different creamy middle too. If you need gluten-free bread, pick a thick sturdy slice so it stands up during frying.
Save Pin
Ideas for Serving
These sandwiches turn any brunch into a main event, especially with coffee and whipped cream on the side. Try making them for a late night movie snack or as a fun dessert at dinner. Want to fancy it up? Melt some chocolate over the top or plate with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
History and Traditions
Fried sandwiches have roots in both American and European food, inspired by French toast and classic bakery treats. Combining cheesecake flavors with handheld sandwiches gives you the comfort of New York sweets in a fun, casual way for breakfast or parties.
Common Questions
- → Can I swap out the bread type?
Totally! While challah or brioche turns out soft and rich, sourdough or plain white bread can also hold the gooey fillings just fine.
- → How do I stop the filling from oozing out?
Gently press the outside edges of your sandwich to seal it up, then make sure that cream cheese lines the bread all the way so the filling stays put while you fry.
- → What can add some crunch here?
Toss in some chopped pecans or almonds with the cheese spread, or sprinkle them between the slices to get that extra crunchy bite.
- → Can I make these in advance?
Yep! Stack them up and chill them before going in the egg dip. Just wait to fry until you’re ready to eat for the crispiest results.
- → Which other jams can I try?
Go for raspberry, mixed berry, or apricot jam if you want a different pop of flavor in each sandwich.
- → Best way to reheat them?
Toss cold sandwiches in a skillet or oven till they’re hot and crispy again. Skip the microwave because it’ll make them soggy.