Save Pin
When I'm craving those punchy flavors from an old-school Italian sandwich but want something lighter, I whip up this all-in-one pasta salad. Savory meats, rich cheese, tangy veggies, and crunchy lettuce get tossed with al dente noodles for a super refreshing dish. It's always a hit at family get-togethers—way more fun to eat than a regular sandwich, too!
The first time I made this, it vanished before the burgers hit the grill at a BBQ. Now I always bring a big bowl to potlucks because it disappears quick!
Tasty Ingredients
- Romaine lettuce shredded: adds crisp freshness and stays crunchy even with dressing
- Grape tomatoes halved: little bursts of juice that taste sweet and bright
- Pink onion chopped: pick a gentler, milder onion for the best blend
- Sliced black olives: gives you plenty of salty flavor and color
- Banana peppers chopped: grab a jar of firm, bright yellow ones for pop and bite
- Provolone cheese cubed: go for spicy provolone if you want an extra kick
- Muenster cheese cubed: works perfectly to mellow out the tangy veggies
- Mini pepperoni: tiny slices mean you get meaty spots throughout
- Salami chopped: choose peppery, good quality slices for best taste
- Dry pasta: twisted shapes like Goodles Loopdy-Loos are best for holding onto dressing
Irresistible Instructions
- Dress and Chill:
- Drizzle your dressing all over the whole bowl. Make sure you toss so everything is shiny and coated. Seal with plastic wrap and let it cool in the fridge for a good hour so it really soaks in. Give it another toss before you serve it up.
- Prepare and Add Dressing:
- Grab a small bowl and whisk together your chosen Italian-style dressing. It could be a punchy vinaigrette or your favorite hoagie spread. Just whisk until it's smooth and well mixed.
- Combine Meats Cheeses and Veggies:
- Throw in all the meats, cheese cubes, veggies, and your fresh lettuce with the chilled pasta in a big bowl. Stir gently with big spoons until every bit gets some of everything.
- Cook the Pasta:
- Time for pasta! Get a big pot of salty water boiling, add your noodles, and boil just till they're a little firm (al dente). Drain them quick and rinse with cold water to chill fast, then shake off as much water as you can. Move to a mixing bowl and get ready to build your salad.
Save Pin
I'm obsessed with the banana peppers here. That tangy, crunchy bite always takes me right back to summer hoagie days on the boardwalk with my cousins.
Leftovers and Storage
Pop any leftovers in a sealed container and keep in the fridge—they’ll be good for up to two days. A quick toss before eating will get everything mixed back up, since it settles a little. Too dry? Just splash in some dressing or olive oil to perk things back up.
Switch It Up
No muenster? Try mozzarella or sharp cheddar. Swap in spicy capicola if you want more zip. Not into banana peppers? Fresh red bell pepper works great, too. Just use what you've got!
Save Pin
Fun Ways to Serve
Load up a big serving platter and scatter extra lettuce over the top so it looks straight from a deli. It’s great next to grilled sausage or a cozy veggie soup. For parties, scoop into little cups for handy snacking.
Backstory and Inspiration
This salad takes cues from the hearty Italian-American subs full of meat, tangy veggies, and cheese. Turning that combo into a cold pasta dish means everyone can share—and it’s all about putting a tasty spin on comfort classics.
Common Questions
- → Which pasta shapes work best?
Chunky noodles like penne, spiral rotini, or those twisty Loopdy-Loos scoop up all the tasty bits and dressing. Cook 'em till they're just firm for top texture.
- → Can I swap out meats or cheese?
Definitely—try turkey, ham, mozzarella, cheddar, or whatever deli favorites you like. Make it your own with the mix-ins you’re into.
- → How long will this stay fresh?
You can keep it chilled in the fridge for a couple days and it keeps its flavor. Just stir before eating and make sure it’s covered tight.
- → Do I need to add pepper relish?
No, but spicy or sweet pepper relish gives it a nice kick. If you’ve got hoagie spread or a jar of hot peppers, those work great too.
- → What’s a tasty way to serve it?
Spoon it up cold! It’s great all on its own or next to burgers and grilled stuff. Pile on extra crisp veggies or lettuce if you’re craving crunch.