Save Pin
Every time sweet pineapple and rich, melted sugar fill the kitchen, I’m reminded of sunny days baking with my mom. These cookies happened because we stumbled onto a can of pineapple rings begging for something new. Watching those shiny rings brown up on buttery cookies? It just felt like packing a bit of sunshine into every single snack.
I first had something like this years ago at a cookout. Someone showed up with pineapple upside-down cake cookies. That fresh, zingy pineapple smashed into buttery cookie dough completely won me over. I decided to come up with a version that kept things easy so the pineapple would shine, no fuss or heavy-handed flavors.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Canned pineapple rings: these need to be patted dry and are the real star; look for ones that aren’t banged up or sticky with syrup
- Butter (unsalted): makes everything rich and soft if you let it sit out so it mixes in easily
- Granulated sugar: sweetens up the dough and melts for a caramel crackle on top
- Egg: holds the dough together and makes it chewy; best if it’s a large one
- Vanilla extract: gives the dough a hint of cozy, familiar flavor; real stuff is best
- All-purpose flour: forms the backbone; sift first so it’s light, never lumpy
- Baking soda: lifts the dough as it bakes and keeps cookies from being dense
- Salt: evens out all that sweetness so nothing tastes flat; use fine salt so it blends easily
- Extra sugar: toss some over the fruit right before baking for a glitzy, gold finish
When you’re buying canned pineapple, check the rings for even size—makes every cookie look sharp. Remember, butter that’s not cold mixes way better and makes a difference when you cream it in.
How To Make It
- Cool Down:
- After baking, leave cookies on the pan for a few minutes so the pineapple hangs on tight and the cookies don’t lose their shape.
- Let’s Get Crispy:
- Pop them into a medium-hot oven so the edges get lightly golden, but the centers stay pillow soft.
- Pineapple Time:
- Place a pineapple ring on each dough blob and press slightly. Dust a little sugar over each one so the tops get that golden crunch.
- Shape It Up:
- Make even-sized balls from the dough, press them down gently—this helps the fruit stay put and bakes everything evenly.
- Dry Meets Wet:
- Whisk together flour, salt, and baking soda on the side before adding them, so the dough isn’t overmixed or tough.
- Tie It Together:
- Beat your egg and vanilla into the butter mixture—brings smoothness and flavor all around.
- Start Blending:
- First, whip up the sugar and butter until nice and fluffy to trap air for softer cookies.
Save Pin
Top Highlights
- Crispy-edged, soft-centered cookies stuffed with juicy, caramelized pineapple
- Pineapple gives these treats a bright, tropical flavor twist on the classic sugar cookie
- Easy list of ingredients means these work anytime, even if you’re out of fancy stuff
One time, I skipped drying off the pineapple before baking and wound up with floppy, gooey cookies that spread way too much. Lesson learned: gently pressing each ring with a towel is a tiny job with huge pay-off—the cookies come out just right every time now.
Prep-Ahead Moves
Make the dough early and stash it in the fridge; it’ll be good for 2 days. Then roll them out, add the pineapple, and bake so everything stays bright and soft. Freeze them for up to 3 months too—just let the dough thaw overnight in your fridge before rolling out.
Taste Switch-Ups
Sprinkle in cinnamon or nutmeg if you want some cozy spices. Toss in a little lime zest with the butter for zing. Or, go for fresh pineapple rings if you can grab some—they make the cookies extra colorful and juicy.
Smart Kitchen Gear
An electric mixer helps you whip up butter and sugar fast. Flexible spatulas scrape bowls clean so you don’t miss a bit. Parchment paper on your pans keeps sticking away and means barely any mess at the end.
Insider Tips
- Pineapple rings need a good pat dry so you don’t end up with cookies that go flat or soggy
- Mix your dough only till everything comes together—overdoing it makes cookies tough
- Scatter sugar right over the pineapple before hitting the oven for that shiny, crunchy top
Save Pin
Common Questions
- → How can I keep pineapple rings from making the cookies soggy?
Be sure to drain the pineapple slices well and pat them dry before you press them onto the dough. This cuts down on extra moisture while baking.
- → What’s the trick to getting that caramelized sugar on top?
Right after putting the pineapple ring on the cookie dough, sprinkle some granulated sugar over it. When baking, it melts and crisps up for a shiny sweet finish.
- → Could I swap canned pineapple for fresh?
You can if the fresh pineapple’s drained and dried well, but canned ones usually give a more even sweetness and texture.
- → Why shouldn’t I overmix the dough?
If you mix just until it's all combined, the cookies stay nice and soft. Mixing too much can make them tough by developing gluten.
- → How long do the cookies need to cool before handling?
Let them rest on the baking sheet for about five minutes so they firm up, then move them to a rack to cool completely for the best texture.